New Build vs. Resale in 2026

A guide for buyers and investors deciding between a brand-new home and an existing one in Greater Austin. Prepared by Anand, REALTOR® with eXp Realty.

The short answer

In Austin right now, new homes sell for about 19% less per square foot than existing homes, and builders add rate buydowns on top. But extra taxes, HOA dues and the rate stepping up can make a new home cost more over five years. Compare total monthly cost, not sticker price.

  • Price: new homes sold for $184 per square foot in July 2026 vs. $228 for existing homes, the deepest new-home discount of any major US market (HousingWire, citing Zillow).
  • Share: new homes are 31.1% of Austin-area sales, so you'll see plenty of both.
  • Location: part of that discount reflects where new homes are: further out, with longer commutes.

Side by side

New build Resale
Price per sq ft (Austin, July 2026) About $184 About $228
Incentives Rate buydowns, closing costs, design credits; tied to the builder's lender Seller credits and price cuts; any lender
Extra taxes Often a MUD or PID district on top of the base rate Usually none in established areas
Location Newer communities at the edge of the metro Closer-in, established neighborhoods
Lot and trees Smaller lots, young landscaping Larger lots, mature trees
Condition Everything new, builder warranty (often 1/2/10 years) Older systems; inspection and repairs matter more
Negotiating Base price 3%–8%, lot premiums, closing costs on finished homes Price, repairs and seller credits
Move-in timing Quick move-ins in about 30 days; to-be-built 4–9 months Typically 30–45 days

The real cost over 5 years

In one published Austin example, a new build with a temporary buydown and a utility district cost about $55,000 more to own over five years than a comparable resale home.

Per month, in dollars New build: 480,000, 1.1% MUD Resale: 422,500, no MUD
Principal and interest (5% down, 6.5%) 2,881 About 2,544
Property tax 680 (1.7% base) 738 (2.1%)
MUD tax 440 (1.1%) 0
HOA and PID 245 150
Insurance 165 165
Total, years 1–2 (with buydown) 3,890 About 3,340
Total, year 3 onward 4,411 About 3,340
5-year housing cost About 255,000 About 200,400

Source: Grewal Real Estate Group, May 2026. This is one example: many new homes have no MUD, carry a permanent buydown, or sell below nearby resale prices, and then the new build can come out ahead.

Hidden costs to check on any new build:

  • MUD and PID taxes can add around 1% of value a year (1.1% in the example above); ask for the exact combined tax rate for the address.
  • Design-center pricing: a $5,000 flooring allowance covers about 1,800 sq ft of basic flooring; engineered hardwood runs $6–$10 per sq ft installed.
  • Lot premiums of 5,000–$25,000 for corner, greenbelt or view lots, often negotiable.
  • Extras: window coverings, fencing, landscaping and appliances aren't always included.
  • The rate step-up on a temporary buydown; plan for the year-3 payment.

What resale sellers will give: in today's market many resale sellers offer price cuts or credits toward a rate buydown; in Leander, 47.5% of homes sold after a price cut.

Which one fits you

If you... Lean toward Why
Want the lowest payment for the next 2–3 years New build with a buydown Builder incentives lower the early payments most
Plan to stay 10+ years New build with a permanent buydown, or resale A locked-in low rate or a lower tax bill pays off over time
Want a short commute and mature trees Resale Established neighborhoods sit closer in
Want no repairs for years New build New systems plus a builder warranty
Are buying a rental Usually resale, or a discounted quick move-in Lower total cost and no MUD; owner-occupant incentives often don't apply
Need to move in 30 days Either: resale or a finished quick move-in Both can close in about a month

Always bring your own agent to a new build. The builder's salesperson represents the builder. Builders typically pay the buyer's agent, but only if the agent is registered on your first visit.

Next step

  • Buyers: book a 15-minute call. I'll compare a new build and a resale home you like side by side, by full monthly cost including taxes, HOA and the rate after any buydown.
  • Investors: request a free analysis of any new or resale home: price after incentives, expected rent and holding costs.
  • Sellers: your home competes with builder incentives. Get a free pricing plan that shows how to win buyers anyway.

Anand, REALTOR® · eXp Realty · (737) 403-2842 · ananda.venkatesha@exprealty.com · Book a call · TREC #857896-SA

Figures are approximate and change often; verify taxes, HOA dues, incentives and loan terms for any specific home.